Friday September 26, 2008
This I Believe #34
Dance magic, dance
Jump magic, jump
...should instead go:
Pants, magic pants
Junk, magic junk
Note the commas. If you have no idea what I'm talking about, I can only suggest that you probably didn't see the movie on the big screen. Boy, that was a lot of information about David Bowie.
(For those of you keeping track, yes, this the second "The I Believe" post in a row that's about the lyrics to David Bowie songs. Will this trend continue? No man can say...)
TrackBack URL for this entry:
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference This I Believe #34:
See also: Areaology, the study of David Bowie's Area:
How do you parse the sentence: "The church of man love is such a holy place to be?"
Posted by: Mike T. at Sep 26, 2008 4:29:37 PM
Mike T, allow me to refer you to the online demo of the English Resource Grammar. Among others, it produces this parse (somewhat simplified) for that sentence:
[S [S [NP the church [PP of [NP man love]]] [VP is [NP [DET such a] holy place]] [PP to [VP be]]]
Notice in particular the noun-noun compound man love, the multiword determiner such a, and the high attachment of the infinitival phrase to be (which the ERG calls a prepositional phrase, interestingly). The semantic interpretation, translated from Minimal Recursion Semantics, could be roughly glossed as:
"there is a church, the church is of man-love, and the church is such-a holy place, and the whole sentential event is in order to be"
I'm not sure that's quite the right reading of the infinitival phrase, though. I think that (such|so) ... (to|for) V might be a complex constructional idiom that requires its own treatment, and none of the parses produced by the ERG seem to reflect this.
Posted by: The Tensor at Sep 26, 2008 7:01:56 PM
I think there's a bit of magic sock in there. Or an armadillo, as Spinal Tap might say.
Mike T., I think it's fine as is. You can put a hyphen between man and love if you wish, but it's not necessary.
Posted by: tim maguire at Sep 30, 2008 12:44:49 PM
Posted by: Viola at Sep 30, 2008 10:07:43 PM
What? Oh heavens, no! You can't skip the comma in "the Church of Man, love, is such a holy place to be" (this secular humanist church, my dear, is such a holy place to be) All the deliciousness of the double meaning gets blanched out by so much verbal salt!
Posted by: illegible at Nov 8, 2008 10:02:54 AM
LOL! You would have made one great medical transcriptionist--we are all anal about grammar, punctuation, and spelling, among other things. From as far back as I can remember, I have always loved reading and collecting words like some people collect stamps or baseball cards. As my vocabulary grew, then I learned that I also loved to write, to paint a verbal picture. The written word--we need more of it, we need to spend more time in thoughtful process.
That movie really scared the crap out of me. We watched it as a class when I was in 6th grade, and I felt like I should be laughing but I was too scared.